1919-1920

The Maker Dreams - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
Enter the Hero - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
The Twelve Pound Look - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
The Workhouse Ward - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
Rosalie - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Old Lady Shows Her Medals - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Florist Shop - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Rising of the Moon - Mrs. H.W. Packard
Rosalind - Mrs. H.W. Packard
The Four Flushers - Mrs. H.W. Packard
Mrs. Pat and the Law - Mrs. William Hanssler
The Jackdaw - Mrs. William Hanssler
The Shamrock, a Dance - Peoria Women's Club Chorus
The Sun - Mrs. Frank Gillingham Morrill
King Argimenes and the Unknown Soldier - Mrs. Frank Gillingham Morrill
Joint Owners in Spain - Director Unknown
No Smoking - Director Unknown
A Night in the Inn - Director Unknown

1920-1921

The Mother - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
Ryland - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
Spreading the News - Mrs. Harrison Wales Packard
Between Fires - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
Purple and Fine Linen - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Neighbors - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Mrs. Harrison - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Wonder Hat - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Everyman - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Indian Summer - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Storm - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
Pan Pipes - Mrs. O.P. Applegate
The Pearl of Thrace - Mrs. H.W. Packard
Within the Shadow of the Wood - Julie Proctor White
The Minstrel and The King - Julie Proctor White
The Shah of Farawayteherezan - Julie Proctor White
The Circle of the Moon - Julie Proctor White

1921-1922

A Court Comedy - Florence Peters Casey
The Critics - Florence Peters Casey
A Dear Little Wife - Florence Peters Casey
Two Short Plays from Dickens - Mrs. W. A. Wittick
The Man in the Stalls - George Wittick
Goree's Showing - George Wittick
A Blackjack Bargainer - George Wittick
Colombine - George Wittick
The Long Lane - William Wittick
The Constant Lover - Scott S. Northrup
The Farewell Supper - Scott S. Northrup
The Rider of Dreams - Scott S. Northrup
Two Crooks and a Lady - Gertrude L. Applegate
Jane-Marie - Gertrude L. Applegate
Mr. Oakley's Telephone - Gertrude L. Applegate
The Yellow Jacket - Gertrude Thelma Barker
The Mouse Trap - Florence Peters Casey
Catherine Parr - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
In the Zone - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Swanwhite - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Sweetmeat Game - Mrs. W. H. Packard
Beauty and the Jacobin - Mrs. W. H. Packard
The Count and Countess of Tolfa Sul Mar - Julia Proctor White
Settling Sylvia - Julia Proctor White

1922-1923

How He Lied to Her Husband - Mrs. W. H. Packard
The Portrait of Tiero - Mrs. W. H. Packard
Lonesome Like - Springfield Community Players
Before Breakfast - Springfield Community Players
The House Cat - Mrs. Arthur Smith
Mary Magdelene - Mrs. Frank Morrill
Sarah Bradlee Fulton - Mrs. Henry C. Rodenhouser
Tricks of Scapin - Mrs. F.G. Morrill
Godmother - Julia Proctor White
The Acid Test - Julia Proctor White ​

1923-1924

An Enemy of the People - Julia Proctor White
The Harbour of Lost Ships - Mrs. W. H. Packard
Underneath - Mrs. W. H. Packard
The Far Away Princess - Mrs. William A. Wittick
Ann Pedersdotter - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Game of Chess - Springfield Community Players
Everybody's Husband - Springfield Community Players
The Locked Chest - Springfield Community Players
The House of the Heart - Mrs. Arthur Clarke
Master Pierre Patelin - Mrs. Arthur Clarke
Lady Windemere's Fan - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill

1924-1925

The Tragedy of Nan - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Embers - Bessie Curran Smith
Wurzel-Flummery - Mrs. Frances A. Wittick
Caesar and Cleopatra - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Lorelei
The End of the Story - Mrs. Wales Packard
Liliom - Julia Proctor White

1925-1926

Outward Bound - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Step-Mother - Mrs. Wm. A. Wittick
Cricket on the Hearth - Mrs. Wm. A. Wittick
R.U.R. - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
You and I - Miss Abigial Dunn
Mansions - Hope Summers
Colombine - Hope Summer

1926-1927

The Road to Yesterday - Julia Proctor White
The Festival - Louise Fritz
Sun-Up - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
The Miser's Mill - Julia Proctor White
Tartuffe, The Hypocrite - Mrs. Wm. A. Wittick
Cousin Kate - Miss Abigail Dunn
Peter the Rock - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill

1927-1928

The Dover Road - Mrs. Wm. A. Wittick
Three Queens - Julia Proctor White
Outward Bound - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Spread Eagle - Leonard Nachman
Mist - Mrs. W.H. Packard
Beauty & Jacobin - Mrs. W.H. Packard
Craig's Wife - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Beggar On Horseback - Julia Proctor White

1928-1929

The Stronger Woman - Mrs. W.A. Wittick
The Grand Cham's Diamond - Mrs. W.A. Wittick
Hyacinth Halvey - Mrs. W.A. Wittick
The Bad Man - Sara Bennett Bloom
Chicago - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Finders Keepers - Dorothy Powers Blomeyer
A Minuet - Dorothy Powers Blomeyer
The Dear Departed Dorothy Powers Blomeyer
Children of the Moon - The Canton Players
Once There Was a Princess - Mrs. H. Ray Dunshee
The Good Hope - Mrs. Frank G. Morrill
Expressing Willie - Mrs. Eldridge Benton

1929-1930

Alice Sit by the Fire - Mrs. Frances Wittick
Fallen Angels - Miss Elisabeth Cooley
Holiday - Rolf E.W. Montgomery
Make-Believe - H. Ray Dunshee
The First Year - Mrs. Harris P. Blomeyer
Erstwhile Susan - Mrs. W.A. Wittick
The Freiburg Passion Play - Under the auspices of Peoria Players